Hot Chocolate Peppermint Fudge

The chocolate turns glossy as it melts, and the cocoa mix gives the whole pan that familiar hot-chocolate taste before it even chills. I like this Hot Chocolate Peppermint Fudge because it gets its smooth texture from a short, gentle melt instead of a long stretch of stirring over direct heat. Sweetened condensed milk brings sweetness and body to the chocolate, while a little butter helps the mixture melt into an even, spreadable base. Once the peppermint extract goes in, the fudge is ready for its marshmallow-and-candy topping. Keep the pieces of peppermint candy finely crushed so every bite gets … Read more

Cinnamon Apple Crumb Cake

The crumb topping is the first thing you notice when this cake comes out of the oven: it’s golden, uneven, and dotted with cinnamon. Underneath, there’s a soft cake layer with apple pieces in every bite. I like this Cinnamon Apple Crumb Cake because the batter and topping come together in separate bowls, so the finished squares have a clear, buttery crumb instead of a topping that vanishes into the cake. Sour cream gives the cake a tender, moist texture, while firm apples keep their shape as they bake. The topping gets its texture from melted, cooled butter stirred into … Read more

Layered Cornbread Cake with Honey Butter Frosting

The batter has a faintly sandy look before it goes into the pans, but that settles into a tender crumb as the cakes bake. This layered cornbread cake lands between a classic yellow cake and sweet cornbread: soft enough for a proper slice, with cornmeal flavor that doesn’t get lost under the frosting. I like the contrast of the lightly grainy cake and the smooth honey butter frosting. The honey gives the topping a warm, rounded sweetness, while the two layers keep each slice balanced instead of frosting-heavy. It’s a good cake to make when you want something familiar with … Read more

Hot Chocolate Cake

When the boiling water goes into the bowl, the batter suddenly turns loose and pourable. The first time I made this Hot Chocolate Cake, that thin texture made me want to reach for more flour. Resist that urge: the batter is meant to look much thinner than a typical cake batter, and it bakes into a soft, moist crumb. The cake gets its hot-cocoa character from natural cocoa and sweetened hot cocoa mix, then a fluffy marshmallow frosting goes over the top once the cake is completely cool. I like that everything bakes in one 9×13-inch pan, so there’s no … Read more

Apple Crisp Stuffed Apples

The topping turns golden before the apples do, and that little timing mismatch is the detail to watch with stuffed apples. I bake these apple crisp stuffed apples in a dish with water around them, which gives the fruit time to soften while the oat crumble browns on top. The first time I made them, I kept checking the topping and nearly pulled the pan too early; a knife slipping easily into the apple is the better doneness cue. The filling is a simple crisp topping: oats, flour, brown sugar, cinnamon, salt, and cold butter rubbed together until you have … Read more

Gingerbread White Chocolate Chip Cookies

As the first tray comes out of the oven, ginger and cinnamon rise from the warm cookies before you even reach the baking sheet. The edges are set, but the centers still look tender; after cooling, they keep that soft bite instead of turning crisp all the way through. That contrast is what makes these gingerbread white chocolate chip cookies feel like more than a plain spiced cookie. The dough has a deep molasses note, with ginger leading and cinnamon and cloves filling in behind it. White chocolate brings a creamy sweetness to each bite, balancing the spices without drowning … Read more

Levain Bakery Rocky Road Cookies

At 400°F, the edges of these big cookies set while the centers still look soft, and that contrast is exactly what you want. Rocky road can turn into a sticky mess when marshmallows melt onto the pan, so I fold them in gently and tuck any pieces sticking out back into the dough. These Levain Bakery Rocky Road Cookies bake up tall, with chocolate in every bite and a little crunch from roasted almonds. The dough is thick, and cold butter goes into the mixer cut into pieces rather than softened on the counter. Give the butter and sugars their … Read more

Reindeer Macarons

The moment these macarons look like reindeer is when the little red nose goes on, but the shells decide whether the project succeeds much earlier. A smooth top and a neat ruffle at the base give you a sturdy little sandwich for chocolate filling and icing details. I make the shells a warm brown, then keep the decoration simple: two eyes, a red candy nose, and antlers piped with brown icing. The finished batch makes 24, so the faces stay small and the details are easy to place. Macarons reward careful mixing more than complicated ingredients. I use superfine blanched … Read more

Soft and Chewy Molasses Cookies

The first thing you notice is the smell: ginger and cinnamon warming up as the cookies puff in the oven. Then the tops split into little cracks, while the edges look set and the centers still seem soft. That’s the moment I look for with these soft and chewy molasses cookies; waiting for the centers to look firm can take them past chewy and into dry. Unsulphured molasses gives the dough its deep, bittersweet flavor, and the short chill makes it easier to portion and roll without a sticky mess. Each ball gets a quick turn in granulated sugar before … Read more

Christmas Morning No Bake Peppermint Bars

Cookie crumbs turn into a firm base when the melted butter coats them evenly, but they need a good press into the pan or the first bar will crumble as you lift it. I chill the crust before adding anything creamy, which gives these Christmas Morning No Bake Peppermint Bars a neat, sturdy bottom under their fluffy peppermint filling. The filling gets its light texture from whipped cold cream folded into smooth cream cheese, rather than from cream cheese alone. The layers need separate chilling time: the filling firms before the chocolate goes on, and the finished pan rests until … Read more